But as you may guess from their name, whetstones have to be…well, wet; sometimes, at least. But there is often some confusion over how long you need to soak a sharpening stone and whether there’s actually any need to do it at all.
If you’re new to using a whetstone and want to make sure that you get it right the first time, then this is the guide for you. We’ll be covering everything you need to know to make sure that your whetstone is as soaked (or unsoaked) as it needs to be.
Table of contents
What Is a Whetstone?
Another thing that leads to a lot of people feeling confused is that there are other sharpening products known as Japanese waterstones and these are different yet again. A Japanese waterstone can only be used with water and never with oil. In fact, if you were to apply oil to one of these stones then it wouldn’t perform as well so this is something that you’ll want to avoid.
To tell the difference, you’ll need to know what exactly is a Japanese waterstone? Essentially, these are natural sedimentary rocks with a mix of silicates that are blended together in a base of clay. The stones are mined throughout Japan for the very specific reason of sharpening blades.
You might be eager to get on with sharpening that dull blade so you can get back to preparing your food. But in reality, it’s not as simple as that and for the most part, you will need to soak the whetstone before you use it, regardless of whether it is a fine grit stone or a stone with a coarser grit.
Do You Really Need to Soak a Whetstone?
To confirm that a very dull knife, a completely dull knife or blade with clear damage, will need a coarse grit stone leading to a finer grit stone. Maintenance and blades with no clear damage will need fine grit stones for sharpening them. We would always recommend using a whetstone over any other tool when sharpening traditional Japanese knives.
The reason for this is that the whetstone will be far more efficient if it is lubricated with water. Moreover, the stone won’t wear as easily, so it will last you longer. As you sharpen the blade, a build-up of swarf or slurry will occur which is a combination of the tiny pieces of metal you are removing from the knife. You want to keep this away from the edge of the blade and water will help to carry the residue in the opposite direction.
When you soak your whetstone in water, this moisture will be absorbed right into the stone. Once the sharpening process begins, the water will slowly be released as you move the blade across the stone’s surface.
Some people do not soak their whetstones and will simply pour water over the top as they complete the sharpening. However, this is far more time-consuming, not to mention how much messing about is involved. It’s far easier to just soak the stone before you get started and then you won’t have to keep pouring water.
So, let’s get down to the main order of business; how long should you soak a whetstone? Most manufacturers suggest soaking the whetstone for between 15 and 20 minutes. This gives the water enough time to properly soak into the blade meaning that you won’t need to keep stopping halfway through to apply more water.
How Long Should You Soak a Whetstone?
That said, you will probably have to add a little more water at some point during the process but if you have correctly soaked the stone, you would only expect to have to do this once, twice at the max. Doing this will not only top up the moisture of the stone but will help to wash away any debris that has built up.
I would recommend keeping a spray bottle to hand while you sharpen your knives as this allows you to rewet the stone much more easily. Plus, it’s less messy!
There are some people that believe soaking a whetstone for 20 minutes just isn’t enough and are tempted to leave it for longer. We’ve heard of people soaking their whetstones for up to an hour but is this going to affect how it performs?
In short, the whetstone only has the capacity to soak up a certain amount of water. Imagine a sponge; once it becomes full, water will simply start dripping off and the sponge won't soak up any more. This is similar with a whetstone; once it reaches its capacity, it just won’t soak up any more water.
For this reason, you can be safe in the knowledge that if you do leave your stone in water longer than you intended, it isn’t going to do it any harm. That said, there may be slight differences when it comes to leaving the stone in water all the time.
Between uses, you might think that it is a good idea to leave the whetstone sitting in water. This way, you won’t have to worry about remembering to soak it before you start your next sharpening job. Whether or not this is appropriate largely depends on the stone. There are some that are perfectly safe to leave in water all the time, while others won’t do as well.
Can You Leave a Whetstone in Water?
For this reason, it is worth looking at the manufacturer's instructions to figure out how best to store your stone. Here are some of the problems you might face if you permanently soak a stone that isn’t designed to withstand this type of treatment.
● The stone may degrade in quality. There are some whetstones that are made from materials that won’t hold up well when continually submerged in water. The materials will start to disintegrate and your stone will be rendered useless. This is more typical of synthetic stones than it is natural ones.
● There are some whetstones that may crack and crumble when they are left under water for long periods of time. This usually happens if the water starts to freeze. Perhaps it’s winter or you’ve left the water in a cool place. This will cause water to expand inside the stone which can result in cracking.
● If you leave some stones in water for a long time then there is a risk that mould will develop. This happens especially if the stone is out of use for a long time or if you don’t change the water will the stone is being stored. Not only is this unhygienic but it can also make the stone smell, which is unpleasant.
This isn’t true of all stones which is why I’ll reiterate the importance of checking the manufacturer’s instructions before choosing whether or not to leave your stone in water for a long time. Another thing to consider is how often you use the stone. If it’s something you’re going to use every day then it might be OK to leave it constantly soaking, provided you buy a stone that can put up with this.
We’d also recommend making sure to perform regular water changes. It can also be useful to add a single drop of dish soap as this will help to keep the water clean and prevent the growth of mould.
When it comes to determining whether or not you can soak your whetstone permanently, it really comes down the quality of the stone and the materials it is made from. You’ll notice that the higher quality whetstones will come with detailed instructions on how to care for the stone whereas cheaper alternatives may not. If you buy one of these stones then you’ll probably find that there is a bit of trial and error involved in figuring out how best to soak and store it.
Tips On Drying a Whetstone
Moreover, some stones are not designed to dry out entirely as this can also affect their quality and how well they perform.
If you’re going to dry out your whetstone, it’s a good idea to keep in mind that this process can often take more than 24 hours. Putting the stone away before it is fully dry means that some moisture will remain on the inside and this can lead to problems with mould.
Sometimes, you may notice that, regardless of how long you soak your whetstone, the moisture just doesn’t seem to be staying in. This could be for a number of reasons but here are some things that you could try to improve the situation.
My Whetstone Is Not Staying Wet
● Make sure that you aren’t putting your whetstone on a towel when it is in use. The material of the towel will naturally soak up moisture from the whetstone causing it to require wetting more frequently.
● When your stone is new, you may need to flatten the surface using another stone. When you buy your whetstone, there may be a glaze over the surface and this can make it more difficult for the stone to retain moisture.
● Check the manufacturer’s instructions. There are some stones that don’t need soaking while other cheap stones might simply not be able to hold water.
Using a whetstone is one of the best ways to sharpen your knife blades but it’s important to make sure that they are properly prepared first. Many whetstones require to be soaked before you can sharpen with them and generally speaking, you’ll need to do this for between 15 and 20 minutes.
Some whetstones can be stored in water permanently which eliminates the need to soak them before each use. However, this isn’t the case across the board so you should make sure to follow the instructions for your particular stone.